Place Team Points #1 Votes Movement 1 Texas 139 1 +2 2 Michigan 135 1 - 3 Georgia 128 3 -2 4 Florida State 128 0 - 5 Ohio State 123 0 - 6 Washington 116 0 +1 7 USC 116 1 +1 8 Penn State 98 0 -2 9 Notre Dame 96 0 - 10 Oklahoma 87 0 +5 11 Oregon 77 0 +2 12 Ole Miss 74 0 +2 13 North Carolina 68 0 +5 14 Duke 65 0 +8 15 Utah 64 0 -3 16 LSU 50 0 +1 17 Alabama 46 0 -7 18 Colorado 40 0 +3 19 Oregon State 25 0 - 20 Miami (FL) 33 0 - 21 Iowa 31 0 +4 22 Washington State 25 0 +1 23 Tennessee 22 0 -12 24 BYU 20 0 NR 24 Missouri 20 0 NR
Others receiving votes: Rutgers (18), Louisville (17), Syracuse (14), Texas A&M (13), UCLA (11), Kentucky (8), Wisconsin (8), Kansas (5), Florida (4), Maryland (4), Wake Forest (4), Tulane (3), Auburn (1), Liberty (1)
Link to check out the spreadsheet of responses here
A few notes:
- I do not blame y’all for dropping TN so low, doesn’t mean I forgive you though
- Love seeing alabama ranked substantially lower than the ap, c/cfb again confirmed not cowards
- Well those of you that love ties will love that neither BYU nor Mizzou were ranked last week and neither received any votes. Pus I don’t care enough to go check the receiving votes tab to see if they got any votes at all this year so we’ve got a tie for 24th baby
- For the first time this year we decreased in number of ballots, meaning we have likely topped out at around 7 voters in our inaugural season, not bad not great
- There seem to be two distinct camps, those who think GA is #1 until they prove otherwise (more than they already have) and those that think they ain’t played nobody pawwwwllll
- This week seems like we have the least consensus, especially outside of the top 10. I’m curious to see if we converge or diverge for the remainder of the season
I just updated the banner and the sidebar.
For the first time this year we decreased in number of ballots, meaning we have likely topped out at around 7 voters in our inaugural season, not bad not great
This is bummer, but to be expected I guess. Lemmy is losing engagement across the board (for many reasons, but I think Summer ending is the biggest) so as long as we keep our core group I don’t think we’re doing too badly. I like the little community we’ve built so far, and I’m sure it’ll grow (especially if other sites commit further missteps in the future).
I also think the AP voters are huffing Bama hopium. I think we got Alabama dead on (and not just because my poll had them at exactly 17).
And I just noticed Tennessee is still ranked, despite the heavy fall, while the team that beat them is in “others receiving votes”… hmmm…
I think our community is on a good track. Definitely a rough start as a large chunk of members jumped from community to community before we found one with active mods and members. I wouldn’t be surprised if we touched double digit voters late in the season as we continue to grow. We just need to make sure to be putting out road signs in .world, .ml, kbin and fanaticous, as well as any other large ingress points for the fediverse. I will say I’m pleased with the aggregate rankings from this community. Radical enough to not be a virtual replacement for ap or coaches, but based in reality enough that the rankings still feel accuracy.
As for the vols, I think this is a solid ranking and if we average my homer take and the full communities opinion the vols are hovering right around 17. Which is what my brain tells me is the place they should be in an unbiased take(but remember it’s my brain telling me that and I was capable of defending Jeremy Pruitt). I mean to be fair, we’ve looked iffy at best due to inconsistency. I firmly believe the pieces are there to be great, but to be great those pieces need to gel for the full hour. And tbf, I was one of those points that the other team scored. Precisely one. But one.
I don’t think I’m lacking for overall engagement, but TBF the poll hits me as homework because other than #25 shitpost votes, I wouldn’t want either to reduce its credibility or ape a major poll, so I mostly skip it. I love that it’s there; y’all keep it up, but make sure not to judge the community by the number of voters.
I’m more looking at it from a statistical standpoint. The higher we climb up to and into the 20s, the more meaningful this data becomes, and more tamper resistant. So additionally I can stop exercising any sort of filter over the data, and the meme ballots can roll in.
Is it bad that I want Bama to start winning again so we don’t get repeats of 2016 Notre Dame? That win haunts me…
#20 is about right for Miami. The win against Texas A&M was solid. And the win against Miami (OH) seems slightly more impressive after the RedHawks beat Cincinnati (who, themselves, don’t look all that great this year). I want to see how Miami does against the likes of UNC, Clemson, FSU, etc. before I get too hyped about this team. They’ve fooled me far too many times over the last 2 decades.
I think you guys will beat us and probably UNC this year. Definitely one of the two.
Yeah I don’t want to be #1 this early. Can we fucking not?
“Texas is back”
- c/cfb
This community can shut their whore mouths. How dare they utter those words!
It’s so obvious that Texas is back. Nothing can derail this season. Just like there was no way that mess of a Florida team could outplay Tennessee.
You wanna go ahead and predict an Alabama bounce back for me please?
- Texas
- Michigan
My two favorite teams (my alma mater and most of my family’s alma mater) are literally 1 and 2, and I didn’t even add any juice to them in my ballot. Am I living in a dream world? Also, 0U at 10 is gross, but I can’t argue as my computer poll had them even higher…
I’d honestly rather we not be at 1 right now. It’s too fucking early. Plus it’s setting me up for an emotional wreck when we lose to 0U.
